Why Automation Vendors Shouldn’t Write Their Own GAMP Documentation

Letting automation vendors write their own GAMP documentation creates a conflict of interest. They’re quoting against specs they wrote. An independent fractional automation engineer protects medical diagnostic manufacturers by separating documentation ownership from equipment delivery.
- When your vendor writes the URS, they define the requirements, quote against them, build to them and validate their own work.
- Gaps in a vendor-written spec stay hidden until FAT, where both sides can be technically right and the project stalls for weeks.
- An independent fractional automation engineer captures requirements with no stake in the quote or the scope.
- Single-function or GAMP Category 3 equipment can use vendor documentation. Category 5 custom automation needs an independent URS.
There’s a pattern I’ve seen play out across 96+ automation projects in medical diagnostic manufacturing. A manufacturer outsources their GAMP documentation to their automation vendor. The vendor writes the User Requirements Specification, quotes against their own spec, builds the machine, and runs FAT against requirements they defined.
Everyone signs off.
And then things start breaking.
The problem isn’t incompetence. It’s structural. When the same company that’s building your equipment also defines what success looks like, you’ve created a gap that goodwill can’t fix. The manufacturing automation equivalent of letting a student write their own final exam.
Medical diagnostic manufacturers, IVD companies, and CDMOs deal with this pattern constantly. The consequences aren’t theoretical. They show up at FAT when the machine can’t do what you thought you were buying.
What Happens When Your Automation Vendor Writes the URS?
The vendor defines your requirements, builds against those requirements, and then validates their own work. Gaps in the spec stay invisible until acceptance testing reveals what’s actually missing.
The URS is supposed to capture everything your manufacturing line needs from an automated system. Every process parameter. Every throughput target. Every integration point with existing equipment. That level of detail requires someone embedded in your operation long enough to find what’s buried in the day-to-day.
Automation vendors don’t have that kind of time on-site. Their engineers come in, interview for a few days, maybe a week, and start drafting. Smart people. Experienced with automation. But they aren’t at your facility long enough to understand the quirks of your production floor, the tribal knowledge your operators carry, or the specific regulatory requirements tied to your device classification.
I’ve watched this unfold dozens of times. The vendor sends an engineer who spends a week interviewing stakeholders. That engineer writes a solid-looking URS. Then six months into the build, that engineer leaves the vendor’s company. Now you’ve got a document nobody at the vendor fully owns, written by someone who’s gone, describing a machine that’s half-built.
The manufacturer signed it. The vendor signed it. But the institutional knowledge that connected those signatures to the actual product requirements walked out the door with one person.
The Conflict of Interest Nobody Talks About
When vendors write the URS they’ll quote and build against, they control both the specification and the price. That’s a structural conflict. Not a personality flaw.
Think about what you’re asking a vendor to do. Define every requirement for a system, then bid on building that system, then prove they built it correctly. At every stage, they’re grading their own homework.
It isn’t that vendors are dishonest. The issue is incentive structure.
A vendor writing the URS might spec conservatively to keep costs manageable. Or they might over-spec to justify a higher quote. Both decisions serve their business, not yours. And you won’t know which one happened until you’re deep into commissioning.
Federal procurement regulations recognize this problem explicitly. FAR Subpart 9.5 addresses organizational conflict of interest in government procurement. When a contractor prepares complete specifications for equipment, they’re generally barred from supplying that equipment. The reasoning is simple: the entity that writes the requirements shouldn’t be the same entity that profits from fulfilling them.
The medical device industry hasn’t adopted this principle for automation procurement. But the logic applies just the same.
Where Things Go Wrong at FAT
Factory Acceptance Testing is where vendor-authored GAMP documentation creates visible, expensive problems. Requirements gaps that were invisible on paper become undeniable when you’re standing in front of the machine.
FAT is the moment of truth. You’re at the vendor’s facility. Your machine is running for the first time against the agreed requirements.
And then somebody says, “This machine can’t do this.” And the vendor responds, “You signed the contract.” Now it’s finger-pointing. Both sides are technically right. Both sides feel wronged. The project stalls for weeks.
I’ve seen projects where FAT reveals that a critical process parameter wasn’t captured in the URS. The manufacturer says it was discussed. The vendor says it wasn’t in the document. And both are telling the truth. The conversation happened, sure. But it didn’t make it into the spec because the vendor’s engineer was filtering requirements through their own lens of what’s buildable and quotable at the price they wanted.

For medical diagnostic manufacturers running GMP production lines for consumable diagnostics, IVDs, or CGM sensors, this isn’t just a project management headache. Your validation documentation feeds directly into regulatory submissions. A URS with gaps doesn’t just mean a machine that underperforms. It means a validation package with holes that show up during an FDA audit or a 510(k) review.
An independent party writing the URS changes the whole dynamic. When FAT issues surface, the documentation trail is clean. Requirements came from the manufacturer’s process needs. They were captured by someone whose only job was getting the spec right. The vendor built to that spec. Accountability is clear.
What an Independent Party Actually Does Differently
An independent fractional automation engineer sits between the manufacturer and the vendor, capturing requirements without financial ties to the equipment build. No stake in the quote. No stake in the scope.
The job isn’t complicated in concept. Someone who understands manufacturing automation, GAMP documentation, and your specific production process conducts the interviews, writes the URS, and manages the documentation lifecycle from requirements through IQ/OQ/PQ.
What makes the difference is time and incentive.
An independent engineer spends weeks, sometimes months, embedded with your operations team. They learn the informal processes. They find the requirements that don’t show up in a kickoff meeting because your operators take them for granted. Things like temperature sensitivity in a reagent fill process, or a specific cycle time constraint that’s never been documented because everyone on the floor just knows it.

A proper vendor qualification process that includes independent documentation ownership addresses three problems at once:
- Requirements capture gets thorough because the person writing the URS has no reason to keep scope tight or inflate it
- The vendor quotes against a spec they didn’t author, so their price reflects actual work, not a self-serving interpretation of what’s needed
- Disputes during FAT or SAT point back to a neutral reference point that neither party wrote for their own benefit
ISPE’s GAMP 5 Second Edition (2022) emphasizes that validation effort should be proportionate to risk, and that supplier assessment should shape the documentation approach. What 25 years of doing this work has taught me: the supplier assessment loses its teeth when the supplier also authored the requirements they’re being assessed against.
When This Matters and When It Doesn’t
Not every automation project needs independent GAMP documentation. Single-function equipment with straightforward validation is low-risk enough for vendor-managed documentation.
Where independent documentation becomes non-negotiable:
- Custom automation systems built for GMP production lines
- Multi-vendor integration projects where the URS scope crosses equipment boundaries
- Any system producing data governed by 21 CFR Part 11 electronic records requirements
- High-volume fill/finish lines for consumable diagnostics or IVD cartridges
- Projects where the automation vendor has limited experience in your specific device class
Buying a GAMP Category 3 product? An off-the-shelf system with minimal configuration? Vendor documentation is probably fine. Your vendor qualification covers the risk.
But the moment you’re talking about Category 5 custom-built automation, the kind of equipment medical diagnostic manufacturers need for cartridge filling, reagent dispensing, or automated assembly, the stakes shift. The validation documentation is too critical and the system too complex to hand both the pen and the build to the same company.
The Pattern Repeats Because It’s Comfortable
The vendor’s already there. They know the technology. Letting them handle the documentation feels efficient.
But their job is building automation. Your job is making a product that patients and clinicians rely on. The person defining what success looks like needs to work for you, not for the company that profits from a broader scope or a simpler spec.
A fractional automation engineer who specializes in GAMP documentation for medical diagnostic manufacturers fills that gap. Independent. Embedded in your process. Working from your requirements, not the vendor’s interpretation of them.
If you’re planning an automation procurement project for an IVD, diagnostics, or medical device production line, start by asking one question. Who’s writing the URS? If the answer is the same company building the machine, you’ve already created the conflict that causes projects to go sideways at FAT.
Questions Manufacturers Ask About Vendor GAMP Documentation
Can’t our internal team write the URS instead of the vendor?
They can, if you have someone with deep GAMP experience and 6 to 8 weeks of bandwidth to dedicate to a thorough requirements process. The reality in medical diagnostic manufacturing is that internal engineers are already running production. They don’t have the capacity for a full URS engagement. That’s how the vendor ends up with it by default. Not because they’re the right choice, but because nobody else had the time.
How does a fractional automation engineer differ from a validation consultant?
Scope and duration. Validation consultants typically come in after the system is built to execute IQ/OQ/PQ protocols. A fractional automation engineer starts before procurement, writes the URS, manages vendor selection, oversees the build, and runs through commissioning. End-to-end ownership of the automation lifecycle, not a point-in-time verification service.
What if our vendor has decades of experience and knows our industry?
Experience helps. Doesn’t fix the structural problem, though. Even the best vendor in medical diagnostic manufacturing automation still has a financial interest in the project scope. Their knowledge is valuable during the build. Use it. Just don’t hand them the pen on the document they’ll quote against.
Do FDA or GAMP guidelines require independent URS development?
Not explicitly. Neither FDA regulations nor ISPE’s GAMP 5 mandate who writes the URS. EU GMP Annex 15 requires a documented URS for new equipment, and industry guidance is clear that the URS must remain user-owned and controlled. The regulations care about ownership and traceability. The practical reality is that ownership falls apart when the document author has a competing financial interest in the project.
How much time does independent URS development add to a project?
Two to four weeks on average for initial requirements capture. But here’s the number that never gets calculated on the other side. I’ve seen projects lose 3 to 6 months in redesign and re-validation because a vendor-written spec didn’t capture what the manufacturer actually needed. A few weeks upfront on independent documentation is a fraction of the cost of rework during FAT.
The Bottom Line
Before you sign anything, ask one question: who’s writing the URS? If the answer is the company building the machine, the conflict is already built in.
Reza Bashar is a Fractional Automation Engineer at MEPSCo GAMP with 25+ years of experience and 96+ completed projects in medical device manufacturing automation. He specializes in GAMP-compliant documentation and automation procurement for IVD, diagnostics, and medical device manufacturers. Based in San Diego, CA.